Accuracy of Eclipse Predictions

Fred Espenak

For many centuries, the fundamental unit of time was the rotational period of the Earth with respect to the Sun. Universal Time or UT (sometimes called Greenwich Mean Time or GMT) is based on mean solar time from Greenwich, England. Unfortunately, Universal Time is not a uniform time scale because Earth's rotational period is gradually decreasing.

As Earth rotates on its axis, tidal friction is imposed on it through the gravitational attraction with the Moon and, to a lesser extent, the Sun. This secular acceleration gradually transfers angular momentum from Earth to the Moon. As Earth loses energy and slows down, the Moon gains this energy and its orbital period and distance from Earth increase.

The secular acceleration of the Moon is very poorly known and may not be constant. Careful records for its derivation only go back as far as 400 years or so. Before then, spurious and often incomplete eclipse and occultation observations from medieval and ancient manuscripts comprise the data base. In any case, the current value implies an increase in the length of the day by about 0.001 seconds per century. Such a trivially small amount may seem insignificant, but it has very measurable cummulative effects. In one century, Earth loses 45 seconds, while in one millennium, the planet is one and a quarter hours "behind schedule".

Earth's rotation on its axis is also subject to short term fluctuations for periods of up to several decades. It is believed that these fluctuations may be due to fluid motions in Earth's core which interact with and disturb the rotation of the mantle. However, climatological changes and variations in sea-level may also play significant roles since they should alter Earth's moment of inertia. Whatever the mechanism is, it is clear that its effects cannot be predicted with the current state of knowledge.

Terrestrial Dynamical Time (tdT) is an atomic time scale. It can be thought of as the time that would be kept by an ideal clock. Most astronomical calculations (including eclipses) use Terrestrial Dynamical Time since the orbits of all the planets can be accurately described with it.

Although solar eclipse predictions are based on Terrestrial Dynamical Time, the position of the central eclipse path still depends on Universal Time. To convert tdT predictions to UT, one must know the difference between Terrestrial Dynamical Time and Universal Time. This parameter is known as delta-T (DT=T-UT).

R. F. Stephenson and collaborators have produced a number of seminal works in the field of Earth's rotation over the past several millennia. In particular, they have identified hundreds of eclipse and occultation observations in early European, Middle Eastern and Chinese annals, manuscripts, canons and records. In spite of their relatively low precision, these data represent our only record to the value of delta-T during the past several millennia.

Values of delta-T before AD 1600 pre-date the telescope and are based on historic records of naked eye observations of eclipses and occultations. A number of researchers have made significant contributions in this area. In particular, Stephenson and Houlden [1986] have fit hundreds of records with simple polynomials to achieve a best fit for describing the value of delta-T from BC 2000 to AD 1600. An abbreviated table of their results follows:

                     Year     delta-T             Longitude
                               (sec)                Shift
                    -2000      54181 = 15h 03m      225.7°
                    -1500      39610 = 11h 00m      165.0°
                    -1000      27364 = 07h 36m      114.0°
                     -500      17444 = 04h 51m       72.7°
                        0       9848 = 02h 44m       41.0°
                      500       4577 = 01h 16m       19.1°
                     1000       1625 = 00h 27m        6.8°
                     1500        275 = 00h 05m        1.1°

Recent observed values for delta-T are as follows:

                     Year      delta-T
                                (sec)
                    1970.0      40.18
                    1975.0      45.48
                    1980.0      50.54
                    1985.0      54.34
                    1990.0      56.86
                    1991.0      57.57
                    1992.0      58.31
                    1993.0      59.12
                    1994.0      59.99
                    1995.0      60.79
                    1996.0      61.63
                    1997.0      62.30
                    1998.0      62.97
                    1999.0      63.46
                    2000.0      63.83
                    2001.0      64.09   
                    2002.0      64.30
                    2003.0      64.6 ???

Future values for delta-T are uncertain but may be approximated by extrapolating recent values. However, the further into the future one extrapolates, the greater the uncertainty in delta-T.

References for Delta-T

Van Flandern, T.C, "Some Notes on the Use of The Watts Limb Corrections", Astronomical Journal 75,6, p. 744-746, 1970.

Morrison, L.V, "On the Orientation of C.B. Watts' Charts of the Marginal Zone of the Moon" Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 149, p. 81-90, 1970.

Morrison, L.V. & Stephenson, F.R., "Historical Values of the EarthÕs Clock Error Delta T and the Calculation of Eclipses", Journal for the History of Astronomy, Vol. 35 Part 3, August 2004, No. 120 (2004), pages 327Š336.

Morrison, L.V. and Ward, C. G., "An analysis of the transits of Mercury: 1677-1973", Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc., 173, 183-206, 1975.

Morrison, L. V., "Analysis of lunar occultations in the years 1943-1974…," Astr. J., 75, 744, 1979.

Morrison, L.V., and Appleby, G.M., "Analysis of lunar occultations - III. Systematic corrections to Watts' limb-profiles for the Moon," Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 1981, 196, 1013

Watts, C. B., "The Marginal Zone of the Moon," Astron. Papers Amer. Ephem., 1963, 17, 1-951

Stephenson F.R and Houlden M.A., Atlas of Historical Eclipse Maps: East Asia 1500 BD - AD 1900, Cambridge Univ. Press., 1986.

Stephenson F.R., Historical Eclipses and Earth's Rotation , Cambridge Univ. Press, 1997.

2005 July 19